Tony's Italian Restaurant & Pizza

Hina Rehman Edited 2 months ago

My family and I try to support local places when we can - been frequenting this place for several years. Recent visit - ordered a pie with toppings and there seemed to be a small hair in it. When reported to the restaurant, they hesitantly agreed to replace or refund if we brought it back. We did so, but then got attitude when asking for the refund/replacement. They demanded to see the picture, which people don't always take but we did because I knew this would happen. Then, they insisted that it was not a hair, but actually a part of the mushroom. I have never seen or cooked a mushroom hair, so at this point we were just being gaslit. We were eventually given a refund, but my family and I will not be back. This treatment was not worth it.

Sukrity Karmacharya 3 months ago

Unprofessional Behavior and Subpar Food I am highly disappointed by my recent visit. I was given a stale slice of pizza and was denied a fresh slice because it was supposedly for another order. What made the experience truly disturbing was watching the employee immediately throw the rest of the stale pizza into the trash right after serving me. Knowing they willingly served me something they were actively throwing away is awful customer service.

G G 9 months ago

I came in for a simple order, just some buffalo wings, nothing specific. When I got home and checked my order, they literally gave me regular wings with buffalo sauce on the side with ranch. If I wanted regular wings with sauce on the side, I would’ve asked for that. If I ordered buffalo wings, I would expect that the wings be tossed in the sauce already. Never coming back again after this.

Amir Mohammed a year ago

I can only tell you about the pizza. I am a NYer who knows Pizza. This pizza has sort of disappointed me. It's an ok pizza but not the best. I was more disappointed that the pizza arrived with the cheese mushed up and falling off. They did not let it set. See photos. This pizza actually tasted like it lacked basil or a little salt. I actually confused this Tony's for the one on Oak Tree Road in South Plainfield which has much better, more flavorful pizza than here.

Raj S a year ago

First timer . Good location . Very close to RT 1 … it is placed perfect close to other shops too - like Walgreens , Manhattan bagels etc. wanted to pick a couple of slices of pizza 🍕 for lunch . Lots and lots of parking available outside the restaurant . There is also good seating facilities inside to dine in. Interiors were ok but it’s of tables inside . Pizza was actually good . Very thin and kinda crispy and nicely made . My kid loved it and finished it all. Service was also good. Guy was very friendly and was able to give the order in less than 5 mins . Price wise it was ok. Not too expensive and not too cheap :). Costed me about 6-7 $ for a couple of slices which wasn’t bad . Thought of giving 4 stars but this place deserves a 5 star . ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️